Now is the right time to become an American Federation of Musicians member. From ragtime to rap, from the early phonograph to today's digital recordings, the AFM has been there for its members. And now there are more benefits available to AFM members than ever before, including a multi-million dollar pension fund, excellent contract protection, instrument and travelers insurance, work referral programs and access to licensed booking agents to keep you working.

As an AFM member, you are part of a membership of more than 80,000 musicians. Experience has proven that collective activity on behalf of individuals with similar interests is the most effective way to achieve a goal. The AFM can negotiate agreements and administer contracts, procure valuable benefits and achieve legislative goals. A single musician has no such power.

The AFM has a proud history of managing change rather than being victimized by it. We find strength in adversity, and when the going gets tough, we get creative - all on your behalf.

Like the industry, the AFM is also changing and evolving, and its policies and programs will move in new directions dictated by its members. As a member, you will determine these directions through your interest and involvement. Your membership card will be your key to participation in governing your union, keeping it responsive to your needs and enabling it to serve you better. To become a member now, visit


Home » Officer Columns » NLRB to Issue Complaint Against Saint Paul Chamber Orchestra in the Absence of Settlement

NLRB to Issue Complaint Against Saint Paul Chamber Orchestra in the Absence of Settlement


by Jennifer Garner, AFM Counsel

On March 14, I filed a charge against the Saint Paul Chamber Orchestra with Region 18 of the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB), alleging unlawful interference with the administration of a labor organization. The unfair practice arose subsequent to the employer’s appointment of a musician in the orchestra to the position of senior director of artistic planning. The participation of this upper-level manager in meetings of the bargaining unit had a chilling effect on the exercise of rights guaranteed under the National Labor Relations Act.

Attorneys for both sides submitted position statements on the issue in dispute, namely the circumstances under which an employer could be held liable for the intraunion conduct of its managerial employee. In May, the regional director referred the case to the NLRB Office of the General Counsel, Division of Advice, for further consideration. On August 8, the Division of Advice recommended the issuance of a complaint against the Saint Paul Chamber Orchestra, unless the employer agrees to a settlement to be proposed by Region 18.

This decision was based upon the Board’s analysis in the landmark case referred to as Power Piping Company, 291 NLRB 494 (1988). In accordance with Power Piping, the considerations that serve as a guide in determining the lawfulness of supervisory participation in internal union affairs include: 1) the nature of the supervisory position and how completely the responsibilities of the particular position identify the holder with management; 2) the apparent permanence of the supervisory position and how high it is in the management hierarchy; 3) the extent to which the supervisory position is properly included or excluded from the bargaining unit; and 4) the nature of the supervisor’s participation in internal union affairs. This list is nonexhaustive, and other relevant circumstances may be considered as well.

Applying these factors to the Saint Paul Chamber Orchestra, the general counsel’s office found that the senior director of artistic planning is clearly a permanently employed, upper-level manager who is aligned with the employer, that his participation in orchestra meetings interfered with the administration of the union and the employer acquiesced, and that the union had tried to reach a reasonable compromise, but management’s insistence on having unfettered access to orchestra meetings was unreasonable. Under the totality of circumstances, the employer’s conduct has been unfair.

Region 18 will draft a settlement agreement for the parties in the hope that further administrative and judicial proceedings can be avoided. The settlement will be conditioned upon the absolute right of the AFM and Local 30-73 (St. Paul-Minneapolis, MN) to determine the circumstances and extent to which the senior director of artistic planning may participate in orchestra meetings. If the settlement conditions are not accepted by the employer, a complaint is to be issued.

NEWS abadicash abadislot royalbola abadislot abadislot menara368 abadicash vipmaxwin menara368 totoabadi Menara368